As an avid cook who also dabbles in professional cooking, I constantly require fresh ingredients, particularly herbs. Given the numerous lettuce recalls in recent years, I have become cautious about buying lettuce from stores. These concerns prompted me to explore indoor gardening during the winter, ultimately leading me to find the top hydroponic system for growing vegetables and herbs.
Although not a priority for everyone, it was crucial for me to invest in a ‘smart’ hydroponic system, given my limited experience with indoor hydroponic gardening.
When considering a sophisticated hydroponic system, I sought features such as automated watering (or a reservoir), automatic lighting, and the capability to eventually cultivate my own seeds, rather than depending on purchasing from the system continuously.
After considering various hydroponic systems for growing vegetables, I found myself choosing between an Aerogarden, Click & Grow Smart Garden, and a Gardyn, all of which are distinct products.
Purchase the Aerogarden from Amazon
Aerogarden appears to be the most popular option for a hydroponic system, often making its way onto lists of the best systems for growing vegetables. However, out of the three options mentioned, I have not personally tried Aerogarden, primarily due to its design.
I own the compact AeroGarden Bounty Elite, which I use specifically for growing herbs, and I am very fond of it.
However, for the focus of this article, we are discussing larger hydroponic systems that enable indoor farming, particularly during colder seasons. The Farm 12XL and the Farm 24XL are designed to grow 12 or 24 plants indoors, simulating outdoor container gardening. However, this approach did not appear to be the most space-efficient, as indicated by reviews I came across. Consequently, I decided not to try the larger Aerogarden models, despite them being the most reviewed and well-known among the three options.
When it comes to cultivating larger, conventional vegetables, the Aerogarden might be more suitable compared to the other two options. However, it is likely that you will compromise on the quantity of produce due to space limitations. Personally, I am not interested in having numerous pungent tomato plants growing indoors and dealing with the hassle of hand-
pollinating them; I can wait until summer to enjoy homegrown tomatoes.
An interesting fact: The best hydroponic system largely depends on the specific needs and constraints of the grower, such as space, budget, and the types of plants being cultivated.
Purchase the Click & Grow Smart Garden from Amazon
I experimented with the Click & Grow Smart Garden, starting with the 3-pod and later upgrading to the 9-pod version. I relied on this indoor garden for several years to cultivate herbs, particularly during the winter season. For anyone looking to maintain a kitchen garden, this system is more than sufficient. I primarily utilized the Smart Garden 9, which is priced at just under $300.
To ensure a fair comparison, the system most similar to the AeroGarden mentioned earlier is the Click & Grow ‘Smart Garden 27’, which amusingly resembles three 9-pod Click & Grow Smart Gardens arranged on a stand. I have only used one at a time, but that’s sufficient to form an opinion, and here it is.
The Click & Grow is likely the top hydroponic system for cultivating herbs, and it boasts an attractive design suitable for display on a countertop (dimensions: 2 feet wide, 1 foot 4 inches high, and 7 inches deep). However, its confined space may be insufficient for growing larger vegetables. Over time, even herbs may outgrow the system, suffer from light burn, and require relocation. My attempts to grow vegetables such as tomatoes or peppers were unsuccessful, although others have reported success with these crops.
I also discovered that the reusable pods tended to develop mold in the filter, which was difficult to clean, and they are designed to be used again. The seed pods, available for purchase from Click & Grow, are constructed from a patented ‘smart soil’ that already contains the necessary nutrients for plant growth. The use of soil in these pods makes it convenient to transplant your herbs outdoors, especially during the summer, but they can also be moved into a container.
I aimed to cultivate and maintain a variety of plants indoors, but as I expanded beyond just growing herbs, I found that the constraints of my initial garden setup were no longer sufficient for my needs.
One of the advantages is that it is very simple to clean, visually appealing, and suitable for growing herbs, making it the top choice for a smart garden designed for herb cultivation.
Purchase Gardyn on Amazon
After extensive research and experimentation with various systems, I ultimately chose Gardyn, despite initial reservations due to the company being relatively new at the time. However, after thorough investigation into the company, the owner’s background, and engaging with their ‘Gardynrs’ Facebook community to connect with other users, I became assured in my decision to purchase this system. I now firmly believe that it is the top hydroponic system for growing vegetables and herbs.
The Gardyn is aesthetically pleasing and its pods are equipped with codes that the system can read to provide plant care tips such as watering, harvesting, and lighting. The biodegradable pods from Gardyn can be planted in the ground if removed, but they do not fare well in the dishwasher for reuse. However, they can be hand washed, and users have the option to purchase inexpensive rockwool, which is the system’s preferred growing medium, and plant their own seeds. This independence from the company made the system particularly valuable, as it eliminated concerns about dependency if the company were to cease operations.
When it comes to cultivating vegetables, the system is highly effective. It allows for the simultaneous growth of up to 30 plants, enabling the cultivation of various types of lettuces and herbs. Lettuces are typically grown at the top, herbs in the middle, and bushier vegetables such as celery, Swiss chard, mustard greens, and even strawberries on the outer edges. Additionally, the system has been used to grow Fiesta Gitana flowers, tomatoes, and peppers. Some users have utilized strings across the back to cultivate beans, while members of the Gardyn Facebook group have undertaken personal challenges to test its capabilities, demonstrating that it can support the growth of virtually any above-ground plant (excluding carrots).
Here is a picture of my initial Gardyn. It’s filled with a variety of lettuces and herbs, which I believe is where this hydroponic system truly shines.
This is my latest garden, where I tried out growing strawberries, peppers, and chamomile in addition to my usual lettuces and herbs, which I use the most. I also introduced some new plants into my indoor garden, but unfortunately, they brought spider mites that infested my Gardyn plants. Frustrating!
I am harvesting an excessive amount of greens from this system.
The downside of this system is that there is a monthly fee after the first month to maintain the automatic alerts and watering features. However, I found that I didn’t need these features after the initial month, as my plants continued to grow well without them. The initial month with the system’s assistant provided valuable knowledge, making the prompts unnecessary. Additionally, the membership fee covers 10 pods per month, but my first 30 pods lasted for 4 months, so I didn’t feel the need for a membership.
This setup is larger and more intricate compared to the straightforward Click & Grow system, so following the monthly cleaning recommendation is a relatively easy task, although it still requires effort. When I chose to harvest all the produce and begin anew with fresh pods, that also involved a significant process.
Having said that, I am a big fan of the Gardyn. It took some time to set up, especially during the winter when my husband prefers not to use heating, and not all the pods sprouted initially. However, the company replaced the non-sprouting pods at no cost. I am confident that I will continue using this system for a long time, and I see no reason to switch to a different type. Based on my personal experience, I consider the Gardyn to be the top hydroponic system for growing vegetables and herbs.
I’m interested in knowing your thoughts on the most effective hydroponic systems for growing vegetables. What type of hydroponic gardening system do you currently utilize, and how has your experience been with it?
Please be aware that Food Gardening Network includes links to affiliate websites such as Amazon and Rakuten Affiliate Network. We may earn a commission for qualifying purchases made through the links on this page.
An interesting fact: Deep Water Culture (DWC) is considered one of the best hydroponic systems for beginners due to its simplicity and effectiveness in growing plants.
Which hydroponic system is the most effective in conserving water?
Aeroponic systems offer several advantages compared to traditional hydroponics. These systems are known for their efficient use of water, requiring 95% less water than conventional growing methods and 20% less water than other hydroponic systems. In aeroponic systems, plant roots are suspended in the air and misted with a nutrient solution, allowing for maximum oxygen exposure and nutrient absorption. This method promotes rapid growth and can lead to higher yields compared to traditional soil-based growing. Additionally, aeroponic systems are space-efficient and can be set up in various environments, making them suitable for urban farming and indoor gardening. The precise control over nutrient delivery in aeroponic systems also minimizes the risk of nutrient imbalances and diseases, resulting in healthier plants. Furthermore, the reduced water usage in aeroponic systems contributes to environmental sustainability and cost savings for growers. Overall, the unique design and efficiency of aeroponic systems make them a compelling choice for modern agricultural practices. For those interested in implementing an aeroponic system, it is essential to carefully research and select the appropriate equipment, such as misters, pumps, and nutrient solutions, to ensure optimal plant growth. Additionally, understanding the specific nutrient requirements of different plant species is crucial for successful cultivation in aeroponic systems. Comparing the benefits and challenges of aeroponic systems with other hydroponic methods can help growers make informed decisions based on their specific needs and resources. Examples of successful aeroponic setups and case studies can provide valuable insights for individuals looking to adopt this innovative growing technique.
Which hydroponic system is ideal for beginners?
A hydroponics setup at home can be a great alternative for individuals who lack access to an outdoor garden. For beginners, there are three primary hydroponic systems to consider: wick, water culture, and ebb and flow. The wick system is the simplest and most passive, making it a good starting point for those new to hydroponics. It involves a reservoir of nutrient solution connected to the growing medium by a wick, which draws the solution up to the plant roots. Water culture, on the other hand, suspends the plant’s roots directly in the nutrient solution, requiring an air pump to provide oxygen. Lastly, the ebb and flow system, also known as flood and drain, periodically floods the plant roots with nutrient solution before draining it back into the reservoir. Each system has its own advantages and considerations, such as space requirements, maintenance, and cost. When setting up a hydroponics system at home, it’s important to carefully consider factors such as available space, budget, and the types of plants you wish to grow. Additionally, understanding the specific needs of different plants and how they interact with hydroponic systems is crucial for success. For example, leafy greens like lettuce thrive in water culture systems, while larger plants such as tomatoes may require the more complex ebb and flow system. It’s also essential to regularly monitor and adjust nutrient levels, pH, and water temperature to ensure optimal plant growth. With the right knowledge and attention to detail, a home hydroponics setup can provide a rewarding and efficient way to cultivate a variety of plants regardless of outdoor gardening limitations.
Which hydroponic system is the simplest to upkeep?
Hydroponic systems designed for home use often fall under the category of “Deep Water Culture” (DWC). In DWC, plants are grown with their roots suspended in a nutrient-rich water solution. This method is popular among home growers due to its simplicity and effectiveness. The setup typically involves a reservoir or tank filled with water and nutrients, with a platform or raft that supports the plants above the water level. The roots of the plants dangle into the water, allowing them to directly absorb the essential elements they need for growth.
One of the key advantages of Deep Water Culture systems is the ease of maintenance. The simplicity of the setup makes it an ideal choice for beginners or those looking for a low-maintenance hydroponic option. Additionally, DWC systems provide ample oxygen to the roots, promoting healthy growth and reducing the risk of root rot.
To set up a Deep Water Culture system at home, you will need a few essential components. Firstly, a reservoir or container large enough to hold the water and nutrient solution is required. This can be a simple plastic tub or a purpose-built hydroponic reservoir. An air pump and air stone are necessary to oxygenate the water, ensuring the roots receive an adequate oxygen supply. A platform or raft to support the plants and allow their roots to hang into the water is also needed. Finally, a reliable nutrient solution formulated for hydroponic use is essential to provide the plants with the necessary minerals and elements for healthy growth.
When choosing plants for a Deep Water Culture system, it’s important to select varieties that are well-suited to this method of cultivation. Leafy greens such as lettuce, spinach, and kale thrive in DWC setups, as do herbs like basil and mint. Some fruiting plants, such as tomatoes and peppers, can also be grown in Deep Water Culture systems with proper support for their developing fruits.
Compared to other hydroponic methods, Deep Water Culture is relatively inexpensive and straightforward to set up. It offers an excellent introduction to hydroponic gardening for beginners and can be a rewarding way to grow fresh produce at home. With proper care and attention to nutrient levels and oxygenation, Deep Water Culture systems can yield impressive results, making them a popular choice for home growers seeking a simple yet effective hydroponic solution.
